We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Shelter Island Vacation Rentals

List your property
Owner log in
Check in
— / — / —
Check out
— / — / —
Guests
0 rooms, 2+ guests
Distance from
1 mi
Price per night
$0
$1,000+
Suitability
Show more
Bathrooms
Any
Amenities
Show more
Property type
Show more
Distinctive Features
Show more
Neighborhood
36 rentals in Shelter Island.
Sort by:
Tripadvisor Sort
Newly renovated! Quiet, private, short walk to the beach., vacation rental in Shelter Island

Newly renovated! Quiet, private, short walk to the beach.

3 bedrooms
3 bathrooms
Sleeps 6
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Charming  A-Frame Home On Private Quiet Road, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Charming A-Frame Home On Private Quiet Road

3 bedrooms
1 bathroom
Sleeps 6
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Beautiful, Waterfront Home With Dock And Heated Gunite Pool!, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Beautiful, Waterfront Home With Dock And Heated Gunite Pool!

4 bedrooms
3 bathrooms
Sleeps 10
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Charming, Renovated Island Cottage - Shelter Island License #:  ********, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Charming, Renovated Island Cottage - Shelter Island License #: ********

2 bedrooms
1 bathroom
Sleeps 4
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Perfect Family Summer Vacation Home Close to beach 18x42 pool, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Perfect Family Summer Vacation Home Close to beach 18x42 pool

3 bedrooms
3 bathrooms
Sleeps 6
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Stunning Shelter Island Estate, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Stunning Shelter Island Estate

8 bedrooms
8 bathrooms
Sleeps 14
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Tranquil, Beachfront Getaway with Dock, Fabulous Sunset Views!, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Tranquil, Beachfront Getaway with Dock, Fabulous Sunset Views!

4 bedrooms
3 bathrooms
Sleeps 8
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Beautiful Secluded Family Home on Shelter Island., vacation rental in Shelter Island

Beautiful Secluded Family Home on Shelter Island.

4 bedrooms
3 bathrooms
Sleeps 8
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Private Hamptons Cottage, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Private Hamptons Cottage

5 bedrooms
2 bathrooms
Sleeps 10
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
NEW LISTING: LUXURIOUS 2-HOME ESTATE COMPLETELY SECLUDED ON 8 ACRES;..., vacation rental in Shelter Island

NEW LISTING: LUXURIOUS 2-HOME ESTATE COMPLETELY SECLUDED ON 8 ACRES;...

5 bedrooms
7 bathrooms
Sleeps 10
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Save time - get the best Shelter Island rentals sent straight to your email!
Stunning Waterfront Estate House with 270 degree sea views on 7 private acres, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Stunning Waterfront Estate House with 270 degree sea views on 7 private acres

4 bedrooms
4 bathrooms
Sleeps 2
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Shelter Island Escape Awaits, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Shelter Island Escape Awaits

4 bedrooms
3 bathrooms
Sleeps 8
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Shelter Island Waterfront Home!, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Shelter Island Waterfront Home!

5 bedrooms
4 bathrooms
Sleeps 10
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Charming Shelter Island Oasis, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Charming Shelter Island Oasis

4 bedrooms
4 bathrooms
Sleeps 5
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Mid-century on idyllic pasture like setting with pond, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Mid-century on idyllic pasture like setting with pond

3 bedrooms
2 bathrooms
Sleeps 5
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Views-Views-Views of beautiful Peconic Bay.  Tastefully renovated 1929 Cape., vacation rental in Shelter Island

Views-Views-Views of beautiful Peconic Bay. Tastefully renovated 1929 Cape.

4 bedrooms
3 bathrooms
Sleeps 7
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Contemporary Home on Quiet Country Road/Walk to beach and Fresh Pond, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Contemporary Home on Quiet Country Road/Walk to beach and Fresh Pond

3 bedrooms
2 bathrooms
Sleeps 7
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Luxurious 'Shelter Island Hideaway' w/ Pool!, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Luxurious 'Shelter Island Hideaway' w/ Pool!

4 bedrooms
4 bathrooms
Sleeps 10
Match: Sleeps
More info
Check in
Check out
Payment Protection
Gorgeous, tranquil 9000 Sq Ft home on Dering Harbor, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Gorgeous, tranquil 9000 Sq Ft home on Dering Harbor

6 bedrooms
10 bathrooms
Sleeps 12
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
New Listing: Beautiful Waterview 4-Bedroom Home, Newly Renovated with Huge..., vacation rental in Shelter Island

New Listing: Beautiful Waterview 4-Bedroom Home, Newly Renovated with Huge...

4 bedrooms
3 bathrooms
Sleeps 8
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Summer Sun and Family Fun in Shelter Island, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Summer Sun and Family Fun in Shelter Island

4 bedrooms
3 bathrooms
Sleeps 8
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
The Ultimate Beach House, vacation rental in Shelter Island

The Ultimate Beach House

7 bedrooms
5 bathrooms
Sleeps 15
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Waterfront Charmer on idyllic Shelter Island, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Waterfront Charmer on idyllic Shelter Island

3 bedrooms
3 bathrooms
Sleeps 8
Match: Sleeps
More info
Check in
Check out
Payment Protection
Hilo Shores, bay access, air conditioned ,  rec room, spotless , family ready!!, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Hilo Shores, bay access, air conditioned , rec room, spotless , family ready!!

3 bedrooms
3 bathrooms
Sleeps 6
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Charming 4 Bed/2.5 Bath Cottage In Historic Shelter Island, Walk To Ferry, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Charming 4 Bed/2.5 Bath Cottage In Historic Shelter Island, Walk To Ferry

4 bedrooms
2 bathrooms
Sleeps 8
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
New Listing: Rustic Chic Designer Home on Dering Harbor, Private Dock &..., vacation rental in Shelter Island

New Listing: Rustic Chic Designer Home on Dering Harbor, Private Dock &...

3 bedrooms
3 bathrooms
Sleeps 8
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
New Listing: Technicolor Paradise, Architectural Masterpiece Amidst..., vacation rental in Shelter Island

New Listing: Technicolor Paradise, Architectural Masterpiece Amidst...

4 bedrooms
3 bathrooms
Sleeps 6
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Family friendly home near beach with wonderful deck!, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Family friendly home near beach with wonderful deck!

4 bedrooms
2 bathrooms
Sleeps 7
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Bright and Airy West Neck Bay Shingle Style House, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Bright and Airy West Neck Bay Shingle Style House

3 bedrooms
3 bathrooms
Sleeps 10
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Lovely property near beaches and amenities, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Lovely property near beaches and amenities

3 bedrooms
2 bathrooms
Sleeps 6
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
A FAMILY’S DREAM & THE DEFINITION OF SERENITY, vacation rental in Shelter Island

A FAMILY’S DREAM & THE DEFINITION OF SERENITY

4 bedrooms
3 bathrooms
Sleeps 10
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Cozy Cottage for 2 - great for couples/singles - in the heart of Shelter Island!, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Cozy Cottage for 2 - great for couples/singles - in the heart of Shelter Island!

1 bedroom
1 bathroom
Sleeps 2
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Pristine renovated home within minutes of West Neck harbor, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Pristine renovated home within minutes of West Neck harbor

3 bedrooms
3 bathrooms
Sleeps 6
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Chic Shelter Island Home, Pool and Gardens, vacation rental in Shelter Island

Chic Shelter Island Home, Pool and Gardens

3 bedrooms
2 bathrooms
Sleeps 6
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
Spacious house next to the beach, Ferry and Eateries., vacation rental in Shelter Island

Spacious house next to the beach, Ferry and Eateries.

6 bedrooms
5 bathrooms
Sleeps 11
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
WATERFRONT with Private Beach Boat Dock and Launch Ramp Sleeps 7, vacation rental in Shelter Island

WATERFRONT with Private Beach Boat Dock and Launch Ramp Sleeps 7

2 bedrooms
3 bathrooms
Sleeps 7
Match: Sleeps
More info
Vrbo.com logo
Check in
Check out
PreviousNext
1
Frequently Asked Questions about Shelter Island