I live here on the island and while the 'fashionable' restaurants come and go with the seasons Cana Sofia remains the best restaurant on the island for me.
Moises the chef creates the most beautiful food using local and seasonal produce, after going to the restaurant for over 4 years I am still amazed at the presentation and taste of the food.
If I had to chose my favourite it would be the Red Tuna....or the Sergovia Pig....in fact stay there all day and try it all!
The staff are great and will make sure you are looked after and that your glass is full ( great wine cellar too, don't be shy to ask for advice). It may not be the cheapest on the island, but for the quality and service you get it is the best value on the island.
Have seen a few reviews complaining about slow service.....I don't agree, genius takes time, you are on holiday, relax with a glass of wine in your hand and enjoy the view of one of ibiza's most beautiful bays.....or if you are lucky enough to be there at the right time of year, watch the sun dip
into the sea at sunset while you eat....magic!