We stumbled (actually drove by) this place during a tour of the island with family. Something about the place looked "just right" and once we went inside and saw the others lunching on heaping bowls of mussels, we knew we were in the right place. The local lobster pasta was even better than the mussels! Humble surroundings with picnic style benches and tables. Don't come here expecting fancy, refined service, just wonderful seafood served by attentive, friendly folks.