We stayed at Villa Almarik for over 10 days - longer than most visitors and got to know the hotel quite well.
We're familiar with other Lotus Hotel properties, having stayed at their sister resort in Gangga Island (Sulawesi) over the Christmas period some years ago. Not having been to Lombok before and not knowing all the much about the Gilis, we didn't know what to expect. The main problem with Gili Trawangan is that much of it is about Full Moon parties and sunburnt, drunk youth wandering in droves. Not really our cup of tea ... but we wanted a short break after a 4-day trek up Rinjani and a place to rest by the sea.
A sudden opening in our schedule meant that we could afford the time to extend our trip by a week, the extra time also meant that we were able to do a 4-day scuba course we'd been hoping to get for some years now. While we were in a bit of a quandary about whether we could extend for so long during high season - occupancy looked full online - a quick check with Hery (who is awesome) at reception and the hotel was able to accommodate us in another room for a whole week - lifesaver!
Gili Trawangan is a very good base for scuba training - there are many dive centres from large factory-like establishments like Trawangan Divers to Blue Marlin where you can discover scuba for the first time or train up to dive instructor level. Most are around "central" Gili Trawangan so we needed to be within easy walking distance to our dive centre, Big Bubble. At least Villa Almarik is on the northern edge of this strip away from the worst of the thumping, clubbing music that is on full blast for much of the night.
The hotel feels like a slightly outdated resort with an old-fashioned pool with ugly, faux
rock features and a breakfast dining area decorated in an odd assortment of Chinese antiques that look out of place in Indonesia. Their breakfast selection is not very inspired.
However, their beach front restaurant is a pleasant space with great staff and decent Italian-inspired food. Their pastas and pizzas are good ... their steaks, not so much (to be avoided). We thought the best thing they had on the menu was their seared tuna salad.
We stayed in 2 different types of rooms during the 10-day period - the deluxe double and the superior double. Deluxe doubles are better-located and larger, but the superior doubles were very good too. The superior doubles are newer, so fixtures are in better nick but there was a curious abundance of white/daylight bulbs which gave the rooms a slightly clinical feel. We would keep those off most of the time in favour of lights that had incandescent/tungsten bulbs.
Villa Almarik also has its own dive centre, Gangga Divers that managed by a young, very professional manager called Samuel. He's a good person to discover scuba with - patient and conscientious. Their dive boat is well-run and equipment in very good condition. Sam is ably assisted by another dive guide, Pak Ajab who is lovely and very experienced.
When we had time to spare, we chose to spend most of our time in the Northern and Western parts of Gili Trawangan, keeping away from the rowdier parts of the island, but Villa Almarik is great for its location.
Lombok was a very pleasant surprise in general - we found people friendly and helpful with little to none of the mercenary undercurrent that you sometimes sense in places that have been exposed to mass tourism for too long.
The hotel offers to help arrange for Bike rental (they don't have their own bikes to rent out) but you'll be able to go out on the street to hire them at numerous places. One reception person offered to help us rent one for 70k rupiah/day, but if you go out and look for one yourself, you should be able to get one for 50k rupiah/day.
Not sure if we'd return to any of the Gilis again, but Lombok, definitely, yes.