If you’re looking for “authentic” island feeling, Daniel’s Café is the place to go, hands-down. The combination of the reggae music, island breeze, and amazing food was well worth the craziness of trying to find it. We went initially looking for the Middle Caicos Co-Op. We found it, right next to Daniel’s Café. We met both Daniel and his son Devon—both very charming and welcoming. The cracked conch was wonderful and the peas and rice was so delicious—much better than what’s served in Provo. A must, if you’re in Middle Caicos.