This was my first visit to PEI, and we stumbled onto New London Seafood Restaurant by accident. We ended up having two meals there on two different days. For our first meal we sat on the beautiful outside patio. The service was leisurely, but we enjoyed our server, our view and our company, so we didn't mind. I had steamed clams, popcorn oysters and half a lobster roll. One of my friends had the scallops. We all enjoyed our food. I had hoped the clams would be steamed in some sort of broth, but they weren't. I wouldn't order them a second time. The oysters were delicious - I ordered them on my second visit as well. I thought the lobster roll was delicious, and there was a great lobster to bun ratio. One of my friends had a blueberry ale from the PEI Brewing Co. and loved it!
We ended up having to return because we saw the fish and chips being ordered by other tables and it looked so good! It was! The chips were fine, but the fresh fish was wonderful, in a large portion and so tasty with the "house made" tartar sauce. This was the only restaurant on PEI that we made a point of stopping at twice. I would highly recommend it!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.