Would recomnend the Salty Dog 110%. Everyone on the staff was great, top to bottom. Lunch was awesome: pasta, sandwiches, fruits, salad. You were never without a drink in your hands. I am from Puerto Rico and I have traveled to Icacos on private boats, but I had a different experience aboard the Salty Dog. Awesome day, would come back in a hearbeat. I made the reservation with a group of friends and we all had a great time. Later, the staff recommended us to go and have dinner in Las Olas. Right on the spot! If want to have a great catamaran experience (Puertorrican or tourist, it does not matter), go with Salty Dog.