We thought we'd try the competitor to Graeter's one night to see how it was. About 5 minutes in, it was very clear to us. This place is better than Graeter's.
Their menu of ice cream options is phenomenal - custom sundaes, and shakes.
They have a whole array of chocolates and candy behind the ice cream bar.
The best part - THE ATMOSPHERE. I've only been to 1 or 2 other places in the world that had that old time ice cream parlor feel to it. It was truly memorable.
If you are looking for a great experience in ice cream and sweets, Aglamesis Bros. is a must!