I have been a lifelong Buffalo resident and had never been to Ulrich's. Since I am a Catholic, and Ulrich’s is notorious for their fish, we went for fish twice during Lent this year. When we went for the fish fry, one of the non-Catholics in my party ordered the rib eye sandwich. Three of us who were there remarked on how good the rib eye looked and how we would have to go back when Lent was over to try it out. Unfortunately, we went back this past Friday when the rib eye sandwich was a “special” for the night. Two people in my party ordered the rib eye sandwich. I can’t begin go tell you how disappointed we both were with the sandwich. After thinking about it for weeks we were looking forward to an outstanding sandwich. Much to our dismay, EACH AND EVERY BITE OF BOTH SANDWICHES were nothing but fat and grizzle. The toppings for the sandwich (spinach (cold) , blue cheese (tasted artificial) and diced chunks of sweet potatoes (cold and tasteless)) were also very disappointing. To me and my friend, the rib eye we got didn’t even LOOK the same as the sandwich our friend had. Very disappointing.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.