Everything about our lunch was fabulous. The food was delicious and fresh. The selection included some old favorites and a few exotic items. I'm surprised by the negative reviews of the service because we couldn't have asked for a more efficient and personable wait staff. The atmosphere is truly lovely--authentic craftsman style, not canned ersatz! I imagine that in the winter there is a warm welcoming fire in the fireplace. Josephine's made me wish I lived in Flagstaff and not just passing through.