I am a frequent visitor to Brick. I have tried several of their creations and have never been disappointed. The waitstaff are very friendly and always take great care of us.
The décor is so cool. They play old 40's type music and it just adds to the ambience. If this place was closer to my house I would be eating there at least twice a week!
The pizza doesn't take very long to cook so even if the place looks packed head on in! Everyone there always is in a great mood(probably because they are eating fantastic pizza)!
I can't recommend any pizza in particular since they are all wonderful. It just depends on what type of mood you are in and what looks good. Don't be afraid to try them all!