We decided to venture away from the seafood restaurants this evening and try Matteo's Osteria. What a great decision! Restaurant has a great amount of energy and staff were very engaged and attentive. I had the Lamb with homemade pasta. This was fantastic...ragout was well-prepared and complemented the yummy homemade pasta. My husband had the beef tenderloin and very much enjoyed his meal. I started my meal with Pasta Fagioli soup which was one of the best I've ever had. My husband had an equally delicious salad. Drinks are also well-done. We both tried the papaya margaritas - - another winner! We didn't have wine this evening...we usually do...next time. They have quite the selection - - one of the best selections I've seen on the island.
Our server, Phillip was incredibly attentive. He made some fantastic dinner recommendations and even offered his perspective on where to have the best breakfasts on the island. He really represents the restaurant well. The support staff was equally fantastic.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.