The reason why the beach doesn't get 5 stars are the toilets : simply disgusting. Not clean, smelly, awfully dirty.
No showers at this beach but this isn't a real problem.
Apart from the toilets, the beach is a gem : wonderful green/blue waters, lovely sand, lifeguards on duty, and what we liked the most: no condos/hotels behind.
As all Hawaiian would say: never turn your back to the ocean. Even when the surf is low there are some bigger waves out of the blue that can be very dangereous.
When the surf was too high we did not swam but enjoyed a walk by the ocean.
A must do in Maui.