I ate at this restaurant twice during my 9 night stay in Wailea. The restaurant has the most beautiful views of the sunset, so schedule your dinner around that time. The first time I had the 3 course tasting menu. Our waiter, Alex, was the best waiter we have ever had (and we do a lot of dining)! He helped me choose lactose free options from the menu, and explained all the entrees without having to think twice about it! He kept our wine glasses full, food consistently coming out, and smiles on our face!
The second night we ate here, we ordered appetizers, and Kelly was our waitress. She actually recognized us from a resort we had been at earlier in our stay, and more importantly, remembered our drink orders :). We also saw Alex again and he remembered us from our earlier dining experience!
Now for the food. The first night we did the 3 course tasting menu. The bolognase and rib eye were absolutely awesome! The salad was good as well, with fresh vegetables picked in the garden at the hotel. The second night we had the cheese platter which was very good. We also had mushroom risotto, which was quite possibly the best food I have ever eaten!
If you're splurging to go to Hawaii, do it right, and eat at Capische! Great food, great people, and great views!