My family and I have dined at Tomato Pie several times. Parking on the street nearby is difficult but there is a parking garage across the street that offers ample parking at a reasonable price, so that's a plus that didn't exist in Morristown just a few years ago.
We tried ordering something other than pizza the last time there. My wife wife tried one of the specials - a lemon garlice shrimp dish. She is normally very tolerant but on this occasion she could not eat it. Way too lemony with very small and few shrimp so she sent it back. I cannot recall that happening before. The next serving was only marginally better so she told the waitress who remarked, "we are really not too much of a seafodd place so you should not expect too much for these types of dishes." My meal was a pasta bollegnase that was OK but not great.
Despite all of this previous visits to Tomato Pie have been better, so I cannot use this one experience to rate it badly. Weather permitting they have a few tables outside which is nice. We did so one time and when the rain came down in buckets the waitstaff was very quick and helpful in relocating us inside.
The pizza is very good - if that is what you are in the mood for - and we have had other non-pizza dishes on the standard menu that are pretty good. So we will definitely go back and hope they achieve a better consistency in the quality of their servings.