Anything you get here will be fabulous. They make everything from scratch. My older son likes the hamburger with the crabcake on top. The onion rings are super. The burgers are all good - as are all the sandwiches. Pork BBQ is the best in town - no kidding. The beef BBQ might also be the best now that Mountaindale Country Store has closed.
I usually get the crab cake sandwich. It is well made and very lightly seasoned. If you want spicy or breaded, you will need to find one elsewhere. The crab is just as good as Dutches Daughter but not as expensive.
Want a real milk shake? Try theirs.
I get food there about 10 times a year and wouldnt go back if it were not as good.