My husband and I were there on a Saturday afternoon and the quarters were tight but we were able to be seated quickly. We both ordered a turkey dish; one with mashed potatoes and spinach sides and the other with macaroni and cheese with green beans. The wait for our food was reasonable. The servers were pleasant and responsive. When our food arrived it looked delicious. The turkey was a large chunk of white breast meat and the sides were each modest scoops of either mashed redskin potato and macaroni & cheese. The spinach and green beans looked fresh. The taste of the food was actually good BUT it was all room temperature and not hot. Very disappointing. It gave the impression of sitting around for a while. Although the quality of the food was there, it seemed to just not be freshly put on the plate. The macaroni and cheese was clumpy and cold and the same for the mashed potatoes. The spinach was cold and green beans too. We may try The Hill Cafe again in the future but not anytime soon. (Both dinners were $9.95).
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.