While staying at Hotel Hamar for a night, we visited the Settlement Centre and decided to try their restaurant for dinner (after seeing the prices and almost eerily empty restaurnat at Hotel Hamar!). This is obviously the place of choice for visitors to Borgarnes as the restaurant was full. Good menu selections with local ingredients, nicely presented, attentive service. My husband had the fish of the day (Tusk), while I had the lamb. The fish was excellent, however the lamb was tough and my meal was room temperature. It must have been prepared first and waited for the fish to be done, as that dish was piping hot.
A bit later I noticed the fish dish coming out to a diner at the next table .... the portion size was half of what my husband received. Shortly after they changed the chalkboard sign, removing Tusk and replacing it with Wolffish as the fish of the day. Perhaps they ran out?
Overall not a bad restaurant, and probably the best choice in small Borgarnes, but by comparison of our 6 days in Iceland it ranked at the bottom of some pretty outstanding (and fairly reasonably priced) restaurants.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.