We ordered the Portobello mushrooms for starters (we shared this portions between two) and we shared the pepperoni pizza.

We were let down slightly by the taste and quality after reading all the great reviews here.

I have had better pizza elsewhere in NYC.

Not sure I would rate it as Number One but did have a pleasant dining experience here. The four of us shared two pizzas and two salads which were all tasty. The thin crust pizza was especially good. We also shared a reasonably priced bottle of wine. Would recommend the place.

Hungry after a day of sightseeing and based on Tripadvisor's app we headed to Oregano for an early 6pm dinner. By the time we emerged three hours later we'd had a tasty meal, with great service, complimented with the best wine we'd tasted during a week long vacation in New York.

The staff are warm and welcoming, plus you get a great view of Oregano's wood fired pizza oven doing it's business relentlessly in the kitchen.

Thank you Tripadvisor contributors for sharing this little gem and for Oregano for doing what you do with a smile on your face.

Amazing pizza + Tiramisu. The service was great and attentive, we loved spending our time at this little place in brooklyn.Additionally the prices were not that expensive. All in all just a great expierence

My boyfriend and I were in the mood for Italian so we came to Oregano because of the high reviews on trip advisor. It was a cozy spot with genuine New York pizza, excellent bruschetta and tasty wine. It is a nice date spot. The food is not overpriced. I'd definitely come back.