When this place first opened, their custard was basically the best around like I couldn't find better ice cream anywhere else around.
This has been a year or two ago when their custard changed but not in a good way. Rather than the fresh homemade ice cream as it used to be, it's now this cheap tasting, artificial and not so good ice cream.
Don't forget the prices of what's on their menu! Sheridan's Frozen Custard has always been expensive but they still are besides how their custard changed. I'm probably better off buying some artificial soft serve at McDonalds as it's better and less expensive!
I will not be coming back until they change back to the way they were.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.