My wife and I have eaten Indian food many times and I have visited India several times. She got chicken tiki Marsala and I ordered a combo plate. Mine was around $13 hers about $7. All food was very flavorful. The lamb curry and kabob were the best I have eaten. The nan was also good. The only issue was my tandoori chicken thigh was a little ping at the joint so I asked for more chicken karma to replace it. That was very good.
Obviously I recommend the small restaurant.