I actually have had good Italian food in Little Italy, but at Da Gennaro. Piccolo Bufalo has a great name, but mundane food. The Pizza was flavorless. The pasta was acceptable. The waitress "accidentally" charged me for a glass of tap water and then included an 18% tip on the bill for 4 people. I called her out on it and she took it off (The service definitely wasn't worth 18% tip).