I came across this restaurant on my way to another place but decided to eat here becasue it was too cold to walk further. I am happy that I stopped and had a nice meal.
The service was excellent: Quick, caring and attentive.
My meal was good - french onion soup and hanger steak. Prices are very reasonable - $50 including 2 glasses of wine.
The only thing that made me eat and leave immediately was the noise level. Tables are pretty tight together and the acoustics make it almost impossible to hear the server or others at your table.
I think I will eat in the bar the next time I stop in since it seemed a lot quieter there.
Overall I would recommend and plan on coming back the next time I am in NYC.