First evening meal on our honeymoon, found The Old Homestead online, we didn't call to make a reservation we walked from our hotel to the resturant on 15th & 9th. Got to the restaurant and they were able to seat us, loved the ambience straight away with all the old pictures and corner booths. Caesar our waiter was excellent and informative.
For starter my wife had the Calamari and I had the Divers Scallops, both were cooked to perfection, my wife struggled with the quantity of calamari (so I obviously helped), the chilli dip was gorgeous.
For the main my wife had the 10oz Filet Minond cooked medium rare, and I had the 14oz Sirloin cooked medium. Both were cooked to perfection and tasted fantastic. There was a couple having a birthday and the guy had the 32oz steak, which was huge but looked excellent, and because he couldn't finish it they wrapped it for him to take away. We were both to stuffed to have desert.
The drink was pricey I stuck to water and my wife had white wine, she usually has rosé, she didn't really drink the wine so Caesar removed it from our bill. The variety of the steaks on the menu were awesome, I so wanted to try some Kobi beef but they are pricey.
In summary, at the end of the evening Caesar was very helpful telling us where he recommended visiting whilst we were on our honeymoon. The restaurant is pricey our meal was $185 but for our first meal and to have a properly cooked steak it was worth it.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.