We go here on a semi-regular basis (husband's office a few blocks away) and it's very consistent. It's not ground-breaking but always enjoyable. We really like their orecchiete with sausage and broccoli rabe as well as their octopus.
Their branzino is also very good and there is a great wine list. It's a perfect place if you're heading to the theater but even if you're not, the atmosphere and value makes it a good destination in and of itself.