Our travel party of 6, My wife and I, my sisters and my 2 brothers-in-law, recently spent 3 nites at the Millennium Hilton, and we had the most fabulous multi-course meal at Scalini Fedeli, in Tribeca... The décor/ambience was romantic and the dining room was quite comfortable, altho filled with patrons. Service was prompt, with the full attention of the staff. Napkins re-folded upon return to the table, water and wine refills without request. The wine list and menu is topshelf, and the appetizers and entrees were extraordinary. Both the Risotto and black truffle appetizers were the best my wife and I have ever had, and we have been to Italy!! From beginning to end, this ranks as our best meal anywhere.
They apparently don't spend a great deal on advertising, as we heard of this thru word of mouth and not Frommers/Fodors etc. We reviewed the website and researched further. This
is certainly worth a try if any of your readers visit New York City.