This is my favorite restaurant in NYC. My husband and I first went a year ago for our anniversary and loved it so much that we returned for our second anniversary. Everything is flawless from food to service to ambiance. We ordered 2 apps: (1) scallops and (2) veal meatball pasta - the pasta is seriously out of this world - you must order it as an app or entree - MUST! I had the sea-bass for my entree which was prepared to perfection - it was fresh and delicious. We were a bit full at the end so opted to share ice cream which was again amazing. They knew it was our anniversary and brought out a cake for us which was such a nice gesture. Our waitress was so friendly (but not annoyingly overly friendly - just perfect) and knowledgable about the menu and the wine list. The wine list is great, and you can't go wrong with one of their amazing cocktails either.
We will most likely go back again for our next anniversary. If you haven't been yet, you are definitely missing out! If you are going for dinner, call a month in advance to make a reservation.