We had great and not so great experiences at Gotham. I loved the atmosphere and the service was over the top exceptional. The appetizer I had (ceviche) was delicious and beautifully presented. However, the main course that my partner and I both chose, branzino, was disappointing. The fish was gorgeous and delicious. The accompaniment was too fussy and completely overwhelmed this wonderful fish. (On its own, it was also delicious, I have to admit.) I've eaten branzino in so many settings where it is minimal, this non-minimal preparation detracted from an otherwise great fish.
We enjoyed desert and wines. As I already noted, the service was terrific. I'd go back, but try other dishes.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.