So, when we saw that Nerai was rated #1 for Greek food in NYC, ahead of Milos we were very excited to try the restaurant and decided to discover for ourselves what the fuss was about. Finishing ahead of Milos is no easy feat, it's virtually impossible!
The decor is nice, pleasant and refined. The servers were all extremely helpful and friendly. The food was good quite good. We particularly enjoyed the fried calamari, tuna tartare and pita with a caviar spread. All the appetizers were excellent. The main courses were good, the filet mignon was slightly over cooked, my shrimps were ok, as was the cod. Overall we preferred the appetizers over the main courses.
In general the experience was positive, was it better than Milos, not really but it's different, try it and decide for yourselves.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.