I read about this in a NY Magazine article - one of the only places in NY with actual Napoli pizza. We went late after a show, it is convenient to theater area and was still quite busy at about 11pm. The menu is all pizza including fried pizza. We had more traditional "red" pizzas. They appear to be individual-sized, but know that they are large enough for one if you are really hungry. The ingredients were all excellent, but somehow the crust didn't seem as great (almost pre-made like) as compared to another Napoli certified pizzeria I've frequented. My pet peeve was that they served the warm pizza on an ugly glass plate. Maybe this is traditional (?), but it was sort of a clash for me. Our waitress was very quick and accommodating. Because I have had better pizza in NYC, I had to rate this lower. John's on Bleeker is still the best!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.