I am a New York City tour guide who spends a lot of time in midtown Manhattan. I'm always on the lookout for a new place to enjoy lunch. Australian clients suggested Pie Face. Pie Face is a cheerful casual place offering savory pies (meat and/or vegetable) and sweet pies (like apple crumble or pear and ricotta). Espresso blends and milkshakes round out the beverages. The Thai chicken curry was a bit bland but the pie crust was a perfect golden brown and delicate. The crust melts in your mouth. Seating is limited to about thirty people at one time at bright yellow tables or sitting on fire engine red stools at counters. The staff is incredibly friendly. A big meat pie with mashed potatoes is about $8.00. A mini sweet pie is $3.50. Pie Face is a good lunch option on the eastside of 7th Ave between W 35th St and W 36th St. I went to the branch near Penn Station although I believe the address for this store is listed above as near W 57th St and Broadway. Pie Face is opening multiple stores around Manhattan.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.