Last month I was sitting in Penn Station waiting for my train which was delayed, of course. So I went on tripadvisor.com to locate any reviews for the best authentic pizza near Penn Station. And that brought me to Pizza Suprema!
I was glad to see they open at 10:30am. The walk was really fast. It took me maybe 15 minutes in total to leave from inside the station and walk there and back.
The guys behind the counter were great! I ordered 2 slices of cheese that they warmed up and packaged nicely for me to take back to wait for my train. The crust was really good and the sauce was made of quality and fresh ingredients. It had tons of yummy cheese!
So whether you are stuck at Penn or in the area, I suggest a stop at Pizza Suprema. It is such a better option than the usual franchise food they have inside the train station and took the same amount of time as the lines in there.