My son and I stopped in here shortly after arriving into Penn Station. This place is practically across the street from Madison Square Garden/Penn Station. They have lots of different pies to select from (you can order just slices) and they put them in their ovens to quickly heat up. The crust is thin and evenly crispy. My son just had the regular pizza while I had a slice of their chicken parm pizza. I enjoyed mine and my son (who is a picky eater) gobbled up his. I suspect this place can get quite busy and there's not a lot of seating inside. There is even a sign that says to please share your 4-table seats with others during busy times. Also, if you plan on using a credit card, you must spend at least $15. Will definitely be back the next time we are in NYC!