I suspect a lot of the reviews here are by tourists. Took a colleague here for lunch based on the strength of the reviews - we work not far away - and while the fennel and orange salad was delicious, the pizza was average. Just because it doesn't look like Domino's doesn't mean it's anything to write home about, folks. The ingredients are fine and the mozzarella is fresh, but the sauce is runny (and rather tasteless) and and the crust doesn't stay very crisp as a result.
Do yourselves a favor, get a good street map, take the subway down to lower Manhattan and have pizza at Adrienne's on Stone St. You'll see what I mean. Well worth the trip.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.