I bought this tour for my friend as a birthday present as part of our 50th Birthday trip to New York. Some miscommunication to start with meant that the pick-up from our hotel was slightly late, but our tour guide Isaac made up for this at the end of our tour. The car (Vintage Open-topped Chevy) was lovely, and drew lots of admiring attention from even the locals - unfortunately we had to put the roof up later on because it started raining but that was just our bad luck! Isaac obviously knew his way around and managed to avoid sitting in traffic jams; I would say that the level of his commentary was more geared towards the first time visitor to the City and more experienced travellers might have found his knowledge to be superficial in this respect, however this did not detract from the experience and in a nice touch, he brought us cupcakes to help us celebrate the occasion. I would recommend this tour as a one-off special treat.