We dined here on Tuesday 11th March as we were in New York to celebrate my boyfriends 40th birthday. We had a few recommendations of steak houses from friends however, we chose Club A on the back of reviews from Trip Advisor - we were not disappointed. There was a lot of choice on the menu - I went for lobster, which I had never eaten, It was lovely. We then shared the Porterhouse Steak with mash and creamed spinach with truffles which was exceptional. The waiter (a guy with a pony tail who's name we didn't take) was very attentive and the overall service was great. We were offered a free dessert and had a free photo which was a nice touch and, will be a lovely reminder of a great night. Overall amazing food, great service and we were made to feel very special. Also after the meal the owner came over to say hello which was a nice touch.
Only criticism, if we can call it that, is we were sat upstairs at the back which lacked atmosphere we would of liked to be either downstairs or at the front to soak up the atmosphere of a popular New York restaurant.
If we came back to New York we would definitely return and will recommend to friends and family.