When I first saw this restaurant on TA, it sounded like a great place to take my 2 daughters during our girls' weekend shopping trip to NYC. My only hesitation was that the fillets were 16 ounces. The normal 6 or 8 oz fillet was not on the menu. I knew that I could not eat that much steak. Boy was I wrong! This was the best steak I've ever had anywhere and now I understand their high ranking on TA. The outside was browned to almost crusty, while the inside was the perfect temperature-- they know how to fix a steak. The sides were delicious and very generous. Also, my daughter was celebrating her birthday and they brought us a beautiful tray of desserts to share.
Patrick was our server and was wonderful. There was never an empty water glass at the table; the service was impeccable without being intrusive. One of the waiters even offered his iphone charger when he heard my daughter say she couldn't use her camera because her phone didn't have any charge left. This restaurant was the highlight of our weekend.
If you join their email list on their website, they will even send you a $15. coupon! Definitely taking my husband to Club A on our next NYC visit.
Try this place, you'll be glad you did!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.