Just returned from NYC and stayed at the Warwick four days. It was my first visit. I thought it was super and would love to stay there again.
Room was bright and attractive. The bed was WONDERFUL. Linens and towels were very clean, loved the old fashioned ambiance. Randolph's is a nice place to kick back at the end of the day.
The staff was very friendly and accommodating. All in all, a total winner!
Oh and did I mention the location? You just can't do better. Close enough to Times Square/B'way but not TOO close... everything is in walking distance.