First of all, I want to mention there are lots of politics on this adorable little island. We were immediately told by locals to go to Fish Hook, NOT Captains Choice. So, that's what we did. Very tiny place that serves no beer or wine, something I enjoy on vacation! The food was average, but the service was strange. I felt lots of forced smiles and not very welcome. I did enjoy the Buffalo Shrimp appetizer. Don't think I'd go back....just wasn't impressed. I asked around to understand why they sent everyone there, and it seems the owner once worked for the owner of Captains Choice and they had a falling out. Not a fair way for them to recommend a restaurant. We ate at Captains Choice for dinner once and breakfast, and it was very good!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.