We had tried several of the restaurants on and near Shelter Island, but decided to trek over to Ocean Beach to The Old Townhouse Restaurant! Great value, fast fast service, and the food was more than ample. I couldn't have eaten more if I'd been at a buffet! Great place ... make the drive and you WON'T be disappointed.
**NOTE: We went there on Saturday morning and ate at around 8:30. By the time we finished there were people waiting at the door, and when we came back from shopping thirty minutes later, there was a line out the door of about a dozen people. Get there early on weekends!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.