The Pomodoro is located in Shelter Island, close to Humphreys and other hotels. My husband said his salmon was the best he's ever had anywhere. My spaghetti was good, but a little salty. Our daughter's chicken dish was very tasty, and the Pomodoro is a favorite place of hers, so when family visits from out of town, she always suggests it. The sangria was really good also. The portions are generous, but a)make reservations, and b) consider eating early in the evening, as parking can be a challenge as the evening progresses.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.