A tour we took said there were 100+ restaurants in this area.
A local recommended Mother Anna's to us and we loved it. Decor and atmosphere is not great there, but the food is!
Also a popular stop is Mike's Pastry. They specialize in cannolis and had over a dozen different flavors to choose from, including flavors like cappuccino and mint chocolate chip. Chocolate covered cannoli was excellent. Was not impressed with their Whoopie Pie.
We were told by a local that Modern Pastry (just up the block from Mike's) is actually better overall. We had already gone to Mike's and it's just too much food!