We have been here countless times and each time it gets better and better. We live about 2 hours away from Ashville and will sometimes take a drive just to have dinner there we love it that much.
You MUST try the Nine Mile bowl with chicken; it is my absolute favorite! Though beware - it is hott! My fiancé can never leave without a slice of carrot cake as well. Apparently they are partnered with a local bakery and trust me you will not be disappointed.
The prices are beyond reasonable especially when compared to the serving sizes. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable about each dish and helpful on finding complementary wine as well. The atmosphere may not be for everyone though. The tables are pretty close to each other and most back up to a large shared bench that runs the one side of the restaurant, so you may feel like your having dinner with strangers too. But I have never bumped into someone in Ashville that wasn't a pleasant person, so it's a good opportunity to meet new people!