Jeffrey's is not "cheap" - so if you are looking for a low cost meal for the family, not here. But for a nice couple's evening, it is a great find. Our bill for food (less cocktails) was $62. 6 oz and 8 oz filet, really good garlic mashed potatoes (1 order large enough to share), salad and bread. Steaks were excellent, tasty, tender - as good as we've had anywhere. Four cocktails added another $32 to the bill. Very good service. Nice atmosphere outdoors under covered patio. But you best have a reservation - it was busy - and we did note that a couple of larger groups that apparently had reservations for later in the evening were advised to go elsewhere as their tables were all full and the dinners were not leaving. We arrived early for our reservation and waited outdoors - hostess offered us bottled water (good stuff) while we waited. We later found out there also is a bar upstairs where one could wait - no problem. We preferred to enjoy the beautiful weather out on the patio while we waited.
One other note: it seemed that seating here and at other places in Moab was not based on availability of tables but rather on availability of wait staff. At several places, we observed empty tables but guests were required to wait before being seated until wait staff was available. Not a big problem, but different than what we are used to.