We had the New York Style and Margherita which are their well-known pizzas. Weren't disappointed at all! The Margherita was as good as what we have had in Italy!
The service was bit slow. We had to call our waiter and check-in couple of times. He said the Margherita takes time to get done. However the repeat order was much quicker.
We had to wait for 45 minutes on a Sunday afternoon which was not that bad. We decided to hang out in the nearby Washington Square park on a nice and sunny day!