So maybe we expected great or at least very good. After all ranked #1 out of 67 we thought Ma'alaea General Store would be a wonderful stop from Kihei to Lahaina.
If this is #1 in the town, then stay in the car and head to Kihei to Lahaina.
I had the special - Hamburger with pineapple. The hamburger needed 3 more minutes on the grill as it was still raw on the inside. I ate the outer edge and the pineapple. My wife asked why for $11 I didn't get fries with the burger. As a note the grilled pineapple was good.
My wife had a turkey sandwich. It was OK. the turkey was moist and the bacon gave it good flavor. My wife shared so that was nice.
Sitting outside on the deck was interesting. The view is of the, road, a Coast Guard station, what appeared to be a mobile office building on a foundation, a parking area, and on the far left some boats. (not pretty).
If you are planning to stop and decide order a burger, ask to have the burger cooked through and through.