The waiter told us that once upon a time this pizza place was a music venue in Lahaina and that even Elton John has appeared there. Well, could be. The place is old and rustic and a little run-down, but hey... we came to eat pizza, not critic the interior design. The side salad was huge and was served with a spicy whipped Italian dressing. The pizza is quite pricey (a small one was almost $20) but it was well worth it because they use a dough that is more flakey and bread-like and wonderfully light, almost like a salty cookie dough. In other words, tasty beyond belief. Ours was vegetarian with anchovies.
The service was friendly and efficient. When leaving, take a good look at all the old Lahaina photographs hanging along the stairs.