We visited on Thursday, October 4th. We booked through Discount Hawaii and paid $235.77 for two at the premium seating (normally $250+ tax). We were right in the front and sat with a few other couples. It was a very entertaining show throughout the whole night.
Pros: Great open bar (drinks definitely had a good amount of alcohol and all tasted great), great food buffet, awesome emcee, awesome dancing, best (and only) fire knife dance on the island
Cons: The one thing we were disappointed about was that we were told the food would be served family style, but they no longer do this, and instead it is served buffet style.
Bottomline: I would HIGHLY recommend this luau for anyone to come see- great fire knife dancing.