Similar to other reviews, we had a great experience with Maui Snorkel Tours. Our guide for the day was Jeffery Taylor. Jeffery took great care of us and adapted to the various levels of experience in our group. They matched my wife and me up with a family of six for the tour, so it took us a bit more time than expected to get started (lots of fins, masks, and wet suits to fit) but nobody was in a hurry so it was fine. (If you are in a rush, you might want to ask for and pay for a private tour.) Jeffery took us to a great spot and guided us out through the coral to a turtle cleaning spot where we got a very good look at 8-12 sea turtles, which was a highlight to our whole Maui trip. Jeffery grew up in the water in Hawaii and demonstrates the respect he has for the sea life and the power of the sea - very safety conscious and alert. All in all, a fantastic experience! Oh, and the post-dive banana bread was great!