After reading some of the other reviews I was a bit hesitant. My new policy is that I am the only one who's opinion I value. I had a blackened Marlin sandwich with fries for lunch and it was exceptional. The rest of my family also had great meals. Real brewed iced tea and a very unique atmosphere made it a very good experience. Waitstaff was great and pricing wasn't bad for a "rip you off" place like Hawaii. I would recommend you try it for lunch and judge for yourself.
P.S. There were cats running around the restaurant but that did not seem odd after 4 days on Kauai.